I wanted to find a small crunchy treat for my dog to reward him for doing tricks, going outside to potty...etc. I like these treats because they are perfect size, low calorie, and dry. The reason why I like how they are dry is because my dog tends to just swallow the soft chewy treats. With these, he takes time to chew it and regain focus when I am training him! He loves them too! I just wish they were made of something other than wheat.

Pros: dog loves it, taste, price

Cons: LowQualityIngredients

0points

0of 0voted this as helpful.

Review 4 for Charlee Bear Liver Dog Treats

Overall rating

5 / 5 9 reviews

everyday!

November 12, 2012

by norita56

fromaustin, tx

What is your gender?F

How many pets do you have?4

How often do you shop at PetSmart?Monthly

that's right! My pups know when its time to go to bed because I open the bag, they run to their beds and wait for their treat. They have never turn down this treat! They have tried all flavors and they like all. Yes I would recommend this to all parents that want a good treat for their babies.

Pros: dog loves it, high quality ingredients, price, taste

0points

0of 0voted this as helpful.

Review 5 for Charlee Bear Liver Dog Treats

Overall rating

5 / 5 9 reviews

We both love these!

January 28, 2012

by Cheenilla

fromNevada

What is your gender?F

How many pets do you have?5 or more

How often do you shop at PetSmart?Weekly

Pet Satisfaction

5 / 5 9 reviews

Both my dog and I love these treats! They are great for training and when they perform tricks. They don't have a bad smell. I highly reccomend these treats!

Pros: dog loves it, high quality ingredients, price, taste

0points

0of 0voted this as helpful.

Review 6 for Charlee Bear Liver Dog Treats

Overall rating

5 / 5 9 reviews

Great for training!

July 17, 2011

by AMckenzie

fromFort Worth, TX

What is your gender?F

How many pets do you have?2

How often do you shop at PetSmart?Monthly

Once while I was at petsmart with my pup a trainer came to talk to me and gave me a bag of these and her card was actually stapled to it... How cute!!!
My two pitbulls LOVE these and they are great for training. They're a little bit small considering I have 2 full grown pitbulls, but its good cuz they're fast for them to eat and move on to the next trick...Plus they don't give off any funky smell like most dog treats!

0points

0of 0voted this as helpful.

Review 7 for Charlee Bear Liver Dog Treats

Overall rating

5 / 5 9 reviews

Perfect Treat

March 16, 2010

by DjinDC

fromWashington, DC

What is your gender?M

How many pets do you have?1

How often do you shop at PetSmart?A few times a year

This is the best treat for "Good Boy" commands. My dog LOVES them and they are the perfect size. You get a great amount and the price is just right. Extra Bonus..."All USA Ingredients"

Pros: all usa ingredients, loves the taste

0points

0of 0voted this as helpful.

Review 8 for Charlee Bear Liver Dog Treats

Overall rating

4 / 5 9 reviews

February 8, 2010

by UltimateDogLuvr

fromRoseville,CA

What is your gender?F

How many pets do you have?3

How often do you shop at PetSmart?Weekly

Pet Satisfaction

3 / 5 9 reviews

My dog LOVES liver but he is also a picky eater . A woman reccomended this stuff for training and its good for that but for the flavor, my dog almost doesnt like this stuff.

0points

0of 0voted this as helpful.

Review 9 for Charlee Bear Liver Dog Treats

Overall rating

5 / 5 9 reviews

Great Training Treat!

December 26, 2009

by aussiegirl1

Top 10 contributor
Vote on helpful content and promote its author.
Top 10 contributor

fromNew York

What is your gender?F

How many pets do you have?5 or more

How often do you shop at PetSmart?Monthly

Pet Satisfaction

5 / 5 9 reviews

We get these treats often for our dogs. They are the perfect size for training and the dogs really liked them! Also, we have a dog with a sensitive stomach and they dont affect him at all.

Pros: good size, gentle on sensitive stomachs, dogs like the taste

Cons: none

+1point

1of 1voted this as helpful.